From “Angels” to “Mohabat”... James Longley Captures an Afghan Generation Burdened by War
ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED IN Asharq Al-Awsat
by Mohammed Rouda
12 November 2026
In an early scene in this wonderful documentary, we find twelve-year-old Mohabat crying bitterly. His friend tries to comfort him, asking him to stop crying, but the boy cannot. He is crying in intense fear: every night he has a nightmare in which three nonhuman creatures, as he describes them, advance toward him to hurt him. Mohabat wipes his tears with his keffiyeh and says, “I have become afraid to sleep.”
The scene suggests that the nightmare is connected to life at the religious school Mohabat attends. Later, however, we realize that James Longley’s film asks us to piece together all the details, observations and scenes of the boy’s life after he leaves the school in order to understand the reasons for his fear. Mohabat is the sole focus of this film. The director follows him, listening to his remarks as well as his conversations with others. He follows this sad Afghan boy, who sees no hope in the future and lives each day as though there were no tomorrow. He is still too young to understand what is happening around him. What he knows is that it is happening to him.
The setting is Afghanistan today, after the American departure and the Taliban’s assumption of power. But there is no present without a past, and the past lives within Mohabat, who lost his father when American soldiers shot him while he was hunting rabbits on high ground. “My father was not with the Taliban,” the boy insists as he remembers. His father’s absence has left him and his two brothers, Mawladdin and Ajo, facing different destinies. The first is a few years older than he is and insists on emigrating to Iran, while the second is a drug addict whom Mohabat accompanies to a Taliban-run rehabilitation facility. Later, Ajo describes it as a prison.
We see him crying a second time near the end of the film, when he is with his brother Mawladdin, who plans to travel to Iran. He accompanies him to buy a suitcase and then a ticket for a bus heading to the border. Longley films the scene masterfully: the camera captures Mohabat’s grief-filled face and holds on it. We realize that he is about to burst into tears, not only because his brother is leaving him, but also because he will ultimately be alone in his world, shouldering responsibilities prematurely in his father’s absence. As his brother says goodbye, we realize that the older boy does not grasp what his younger brother understands about what it means to be left alone in the world.
Until now, most of this American director’s films have unfolded in life’s harsh terrain. In 2002 he directed Gaza Strip, his first feature. Four years later he completed Iraq in Fragments, a feature about another boy, approaching his subject in the same style and speaking through it about Iraq under American occupation. (“Baghdad used to be so beautiful,” the boy says, remembering.) Before Longley left Iraq, he made a short film, Sari’s Mother (2006), about a mother trying to save her child from death. From Iraq he moved to Afghanistan, where in 2018 he made Angels Are Made of Light, portraying students and teachers suffering together through years of war.
The director captures Mohabat and other children of his generation playing or reviewing the lessons they have memorized at school. In this, they are like children everywhere in the world, except that they are shackled by their memories of the past and the harsh reality of the present.
Then there is the religious presence. The film begins with the phrase “In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.” This may have been the director’s choice, since he is filming in an Islamic environment that he respects, or, more likely, in response to a request from the Afghan authority that permitted him to film. There are scenes of Quran memorization, which means a great deal to Afghans, but the film does not frame them in context. The critic writing these lines is unsure whether the camera’s images of boys and men reciting reflect the director’s wish to secure the officials’ acceptance of the film, or whether they convey the psychological and social pressure upon everyone. This is because the filming style remains the same, and because the director is less interested in declaring his position than in letting the film do so for itself.
The director undertakes the cinematography himself, using a wide-angle lens that conveys the beauty of nature, even its barren landscapes. The camera observes those mountain pastures, fields and farms without haste. In fact, the film’s editing sustains this quiet rhythm, which unfolds before us as a process of discovery that Afghan and Iranian filmmakers, both men and women, have failed to achieve when addressing that country’s circumstances in documentary or fiction.
With a carefully measured progression, the realization grows that what we are watching is among the best documentarIes of the year, if not the best. It is certainly the only tenderly humane film among them.